pages/garden/guide-to-incrementals/appeal-to-players/index.html

34 lines
50 KiB
HTML
Raw Normal View History

<!DOCTYPE html>
<html lang="en-US" dir="ltr">
<head>
<meta charset="utf-8">
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1">
<title>Guide to Incrementals/Appeal to Players | The Paper Pilot</title>
<meta name="description" content="The Paper Pilot's Digital Garden">
<meta name="generator" content="VitePress v1.2.2">
<link rel="preload stylesheet" href="/assets/style.ClAGozCE.css" as="style">
<script type="module" src="/assets/app.Cxu4aH84.js"></script>
<link rel="preload" href="/assets/inter-roman-latin.Di8DUHzh.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin="">
<link rel="modulepreload" href="/assets/chunks/framework.CK8QU5WH.js">
<link rel="modulepreload" href="/assets/chunks/theme.Lm1E6I-W.js">
<link rel="modulepreload" href="/assets/garden_guide-to-incrementals_appeal-to-players_index.md.CRDB23Hr.lean.js">
<link rel="preconnect" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Pacifico&amp;family=Roboto+Mono:ital,wght@0,400;0,600;1,400&amp;display=swap">
<link rel="manifest" href="/site.webmanifest">
<link rel="alternate" type="text/mf2+html" href="/changelog">
<link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="Changelog" href="/changelog/rss">
<link rel="alternate" type="application/atom+xml" title="Changelog" href="/changelog/atom">
<link rel="alternate" type="application/json+xml" title="Changelog" href="/changelog/json">
<meta name="og:description" content="The Paper Pilot's Digital Garden">
<script id="check-dark-mode">(()=>{const e=localStorage.getItem("vitepress-theme-appearance")||"auto",a=window.matchMedia("(prefers-color-scheme: dark)").matches;(!e||e==="auto"?a:e==="dark")&&document.documentElement.classList.add("dark")})();</script>
<script id="check-mac-os">document.documentElement.classList.toggle("mac",/Mac|iPhone|iPod|iPad/i.test(navigator.platform));</script>
</head>
<body>
<div id="app"><div class="Layout" data-v-90dd949c data-v-5d98c3a5><!--[--><!--[--><!--]--><!--]--><!--[--><span tabindex="-1" data-v-0f60ec36></span><a href="#VPContent" class="VPSkipLink visually-hidden" data-v-0f60ec36> Skip to content </a><!--]--><!----><header class="VPNav" data-v-5d98c3a5 data-v-ae24b3ad><div class="VPNavBar has-sidebar top" data-v-ae24b3ad data-v-ccf7ddec><div class="wrapper" data-v-ccf7ddec><div class="container" data-v-ccf7ddec><div class="title" data-v-ccf7ddec><div class="VPNavBarTitle has-sidebar" data-v-ccf7ddec data-v-ab179fa1><a class="title" href="/" data-v-ab179fa1><!--[--><!--]--><!----><span data-v-ab179fa1>The Paper Pilot</span><!--[--><!--]--></a></div></div><div class="content" data-v-ccf7ddec><div class="content-body" data-v-ccf7ddec><!--[--><!--]--><div class="VPNavBarSearch search" data-v-ccf7ddec><!--[--><!----><div id="local-search"><button type="button" class="DocSearch DocSearch-Button" aria-label="Search"><span class="DocSearch-Button-Container"><span class="vp-icon DocSearch-Search-Icon"></span><span class="DocSearch-Button-Placeholder">Search</span></span><span class="DocSearch-Button-Keys"><kbd class="DocSearch-Button-Key"></kbd><kbd class="DocSearch-Button-Key">K</kbd></span></button></div><!--]--></div><nav aria-labelledby="main-nav-aria-label" class="VPNavBarMenu menu" data-v-ccf7ddec data-v-7f418b0f><span id="main-nav-aria-label" class="visually-hidden" data-v-7f418b0f>Main Navigation</span><!--[--><!--[--><a class="VPLink link vp-external-link-icon VPNavBarMenuLink" href="https://moddingtree.com" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer" tabindex="0" data-v-7f418b0f data-v-9c663999><!--[--><span data-v-9c663999>Profectus</span><!--]--></a><!--]--><!--[--><a class="VPLink link vp-external-link-icon VPNavBarMenuLink" href="https://incremental.social" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer" tabindex="0" data-v-7f418b0f data-v-9c663999><!--[--><span data-v-9c663999>Incremental Social</span><!--]--></a><!--]--><!--]--></nav><!----><div class="VPNavBarAppearance appearance" data-v-ccf7ddec data-v-e6aabb21><button class="VPSwitch VPSwitchAppearance" type="button" role="switch" title="Switch to dark theme" aria-checked="false" data-v-e6aabb21 data-v-d1f28634 data-v-1d5665e3><span class="check" data-v-1d5665e3><span class="icon" data-v-1d5665e3><!--[--><span class="vpi-sun sun" data-v-d1f28634></span><span class="vpi-moon moon" data-v-d1f28634></span><!--]--></span></span></button></div><div class="VPSocialLinks VPNavBarSocialLinks social-links" data-v-ccf7ddec data-v-0394ad82 data-v-7bc22406><!--[--><a class="VPSocialLink no-icon" href="https://code.incremental.social/thepaperpilot" aria-label target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-v-7bc22406 data-v-eee4e7cb><svg role="img" viewBox="0 0 24 24" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><title>Forgejo</title><path d="M16.7773 0c1.6018 0 2.9004 1.2986 2.9004 2.9005s-1.2986 2.9004-2.9004 2.9004c-1.0854 0-2.0315-.596-2.5288-1.4787H12.91c-2.3322 0-4.2272 1.8718-4.2649 4.195l-.0007 2.1175a7.0759 7.0759 0 0 1 4.148-1.4205l.1176-.001 1.3385.0002c.4973-.8827 1.4434-1.4788 2.5288-1.4788 1.6018 0 2.9004 1.2986 2.9004 2.9005s-1.2986 2.9004-2.9004 2.9004c-1.0854 0-2.0315-.596-2.5288-1.4787H12.91c-2.3322 0-4.2272 1.8718-4.2649 4.195l-.0007 2.319c.8827.4973 1.4788 1.4434 1.4788 2.5287 0 1.602-1.2986 2.9005-2.9005 2.9005-1.6018 0-2.9004-1.2986-2.9004-2.9005 0-1.0853.596-2.0314 1.4788-2.5287l-.0002-9.9831c0-3.887 3.1195-7.0453 6.9915-7.108l.1176-.001h1.3385C14.7458.5962 15.692 0 16.7773 0ZM7.2227 19.9052c-.6596 0-1.1943.5347-1.1943 1.1943s.5347 1.1943 1.1943 1.1943 1.1944-.5347 1.1944-1.1943-.5348-1.1943-1.1944-1.1943Zm9.5546-10.4644c-.6596 0-1.1944.5347-1.1944 1.1943s.5348 1.1943 1.1944 1.1943c.6596 0 1.1943-.5347 1.1943-1.1943s-.5347-1.1943-1.1943-1.1943Zm0-7.7346c-.6596 0-1.1944.5347-1.1944 1.1943s.5348 1.1943 1.1944 1.1943c.6596 0 1.1943-.5347 1.1943-1.1943s-.5347-1.1943-1.1943-1.1943Z"/></svg></a><a class="VPSocialLink no-icon" href="https://matrix.to/#/@thepaperpilot:incremental.social" aria-label target="_blank" rel="noopener" data-v-7bc22406 data-v-eee4e7c
. Last tended to <a href='https://code.incremental.social/thepaperpilot/pages/commit/91e757f7ccbeb570d900aaa5b49e6e4874d19b2f' title='Wed Jun 5 23:25:48 2024 -0500'><time class='dt-updated' datetime='Wed Jun 5 23:25:48 2024 -0500'>10 days ago</time></a>
.</p><hr/><div class="e-content"><p>This is something that has been discussed and analyzed by many people, and to some extent, I feel like everything that can be said on the topic already has. However, a lot of these analyses are from the perspective of those with not as much experience and involvement within the genre as I&#39;d argue would be necessary for a fully contextualized answer. I recently watched a video about Vampire Survivors, which has since been taken down due to drawing negative attention, which made me think about some interesting arguments about what games <em>are</em>, and what makes them <em>good</em>. The video&#39;s argument that &quot;Vampire Survivors is not a video game&quot; mirrors a claim by the developer of Cookie Clicker that his games are <a href="https://www.polygon.com/2013/9/30/4786780/the-cult-of-the-cookie-clicker-when-is-a-game-not-a-game" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">&quot;non-games&quot;</a>. Using Vampire Survivors and the video made on it as a framework, I&#39;ll be answering why incremental games appeal to players. Since the video has been taken down, I&#39;ll do my best to contextualize and generalize the arguments of the video without requiring the reader to watch it. For what it&#39;s worth, while I disagreed with the video I actually liked a lot of the way it went about thinking about games, and I consider this a continuation of that discussion.</p><h2 id="numbers-going-up" tabindex="-1">Numbers Going Up <a class="header-anchor" href="#numbers-going-up" aria-label="Permalink to &quot;Numbers Going Up&quot;"></a></h2><p>This is a very common response to why people enjoy incremental games, although it&#39;s not one I find compels me personally, and I suspect it might be a stand-in for <a href="/garden/guide-to-incrementals/appeal-to-players/#665ceed1-704e-4cd0-8263-9a1756b09f4a">progression</a>) or <a href="/garden/guide-to-incrementals/what-is-content/">Guide to Incrementals/What is Content?</a>. But reportedly, some people do just like <em>seeing</em> big numbers. I must reiterate I suspect the actual cause is seeing big numbers <em>in context</em> though - if you start at 1e1000 of a currency and get to 1e1001, that isn&#39;t going to feel as satisfying as going from 1e10 to 1e100, and in any case, I don&#39;t think a button that just adds a zero to your number will feel quite satisfying - I believe its the sense of having made progress, and comparing where you are to where you started and feeling like you&#39;ve earned your way here that is enjoyable.</p><p><span id="665ceed1-704e-4cd0-8263-9a1756b09f4a"><h2>Progression</h2></span></p><p>Vampire Survivors can be argued to have a comparatively low depth to its combat compared to many other games. I&#39;d argue it has <em>sufficient</em> depth and more than someone might expect who has only played the game for a short while, but it still definitely gets beat out by many other combat-focused games. Instead, a lot of the progression in Vampire Survivors comes from a meta-progression system by which base stats are increased by spending a currency that persists between runs. While it is technically possible to win without this meta-progression system, and indeed in many roguelikes players like to challenge themselves by beating the game without any meta-progression, the criticism can be made that meta-progression de-emphasizes player skill by making it less important to have to beat the game. Certainly, in incremental games, it is often literally impossible to complete a game without taking advantage of the meta-progression systems. I&#39;d argue this does not detract from the game, however, and is actually a part of what makes incremental games, and roguelikes, enjoyable to many players: meta-progression <em>augments</em> the increases in skill the player is naturally gaining as they play. In effect, it&#39;s not <em>replacing</em> the skill increase, but <em>exaggerating</em> it to make it feel more real to the player.</p><blockquote><p>Note: There is also a lot of progression from exploring the mechanics and discoverin
<script>window.__VP_HASH_MAP__=JSON.parse("{\"garden_kronos_index.md\":\"iUhWCop9\",\"garden_guide-to-incrementals_appeal-to-developers_index.md\":\"Diny6WsX\",\"garden_mtx_index.md\":\"BRzkTeai\",\"garden_my-projects_index.md\":\"Cznm6ckc\",\"public_gamedevtree_changelog.md\":\"DGS-7PiF\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_bars.md\":\"CxNndqIx\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_buyables.md\":\"DlXMZmV4\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_challenges.md\":\"DEdsv7kR\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_getting-started.md\":\"DzfYHbWF\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_basic-layer-breakdown.md\":\"rhKMtsLX\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_milestones.md\":\"DiBU9uxR\",\"garden_chronological_index.md\":\"CQEy-T7E\",\"garden_mbin_index.md\":\"BHK-Iuf3\",\"guide-to-incrementals_index.md\":\"Q8NHkbU9\",\"garden_vitepress_index.md\":\"CDGDOV5f\",\"garden_fediverse_index.md\":\"C7LEB0uc\",\"garden_this-knowledge-hub_index.md\":\"CUdFhZdq\",\"garden_social-media_index.md\":\"BbHjayFv\",\"guide-to-incrementals_ludology_appeal-gamers_index.md\":\"B6xF3S0w\",\"guide-to-incrementals_ludology_appeal-developers_index.md\":\"Cm_ScJQR\",\"public_gamedevtree_readme.md\":\"C_ZitREW\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_subtabs-and-microtabs.md\":\"C75eZZin\",\"garden_premium-currency_index.md\":\"CYRzDOj_\",\"garden_ivy-road_index.md\":\"I5lUYnjM\",\"garden_webrings_index.md\":\"DVn_-9-u\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_infoboxes.md\":\"9a47XYCg\",\"garden_atproto_index.md\":\"DbIIfL4R\",\"garden_activitypub_index.md\":\"CicDcQ2_\",\"garden_advent-incremental_index.md\":\"C8yXdubg\",\"garden_dice-armor_index.md\":\"CHYRQr4z\",\"garden_nostr_index.md\":\"CgleUUbP\",\"garden_the-small-web_index.md\":\"DB8s7zLZ\",\"garden_weird_index.md\":\"5UcMgku5\",\"guide-to-incrementals_design_criticism_index.md\":\"DIKhcyDO\",\"public_kronos_docs_custom-tab-layouts.md\":\"C9uDrIM0\",\"public_kronos_docs_clickables.md\":\"BvrZ942x\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_upgrades.md\":\"Msxg1C07\",\"public_lit_docs_infoboxes.md\":\"BuPTImhx\",\"public_lit_docs_subtabs-and-microtabs.md\":\"DhbrQf33\",\"now_index.md\":\"Bc55FAwk\",\"garden_artificial-intelligence_index.md\":\"DHIZV-Nf\",\"garden_guide-to-incrementals_navigating-criticism_index.md\":\"FUIN6tkG\",\"garden_my-personal-website_index.md\":\"DwfKlijC\",\"guide-to-incrementals_ludology_definition_index.md\":\"D2MCMru0\",\"garden_digital-gardens_index.md\":\"-_Ah0Mkb\",\"garden_guide-to-incrementals_what-is-content_index.md\":\"BMETYiAP\",\"garden_incremental-social_index.md\":\"D80WDhip\",\"garden_planar-pioneers_index.md\":\"C66vsCjv\",\"garden_matrix_index.md\":\"CeSXZSDm\",\"garden_life-is-strange_index.md\":\"tdVgcS32\",\"garden_opti-speech_index.md\":\"fV3laAf8\",\"garden_logseq_index.md\":\"BiLoV0bt\",\"garden_open-source_index.md\":\"CrbIsKOD\",\"garden_the-beginner-s-guide_index.md\":\"BdmIJg3j\",\"index.md\":\"DsTbDkfQ\",\"garden_the-cozy-web_index.md\":\"BEzt5FqQ\",\"garden_profectus_index.md\":\"ykiRoiHE\",\"garden_the-indieweb_signature-blocks_index.md\":\"BSUq9f2h\",\"garden_freeform-vs-chronological-dichotomy_index.md\":\"CC0rVLI6\",\"garden_forgejo_index.md\":\"2k8RiG3S\",\"garden_v-ecs_index.md\":\"DJKtb91L\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_clickables.md\":\"Cyab8uw5\",\"public_gamedevtree_2.0-format-changes.md\":\"3MaMo5-m\",\"changelog_index.md\":\"gjqAjJbE\",\"public_gamedevtree_docs_updating-tmt.md\":\"37YMR_q4\",\"garden_command-palettes_index.md\":\"aFoJwvWM\",\"garden_video-game-monetization_index.md\":\"eY03jnxc\",\"garden_capture-the-citadel_index.md\":\"CzfQmks-\",\"garden_guide-to-incrementals_appeal-to-players_index.md\":\"CRDB23Hr\",\"garden_garden-rss_index.md\":\"CeZWgVca\",\"garden_federated-identity_index.md\":\"DXhML-Yi\",\"garden_pre-order-bonuses_index.md\":\"C0-qMrbr\",\"garden_freeform_index.md\":\"CvO7JCJh\",\"garden_fedi-v2_index.md\":\"CtSaZdaZ\",\"garden_the-indieweb_amplification_index.md\":\"DT2TYsGY\",\"garden_commune_index.md\":\"DRJ4sRzw\",\"garden_chat-glue_index.md\":\"BTV2mQC1\",\"garden_cinny_index.md\":\"6lP2Zwso\",\"garden_decentralized_index.md\":\"Cbrt43lP\",\"garden_synapse_index.md\":\"C51ajr4V\",\"garden_babble-b
</body>
</html>